{"remix_data":[],"remix_entry_point":"challenges","source_tags":[],"origin":"unknown","total_draw_time":0,"total_draw_actions":0,"layers_used":0,"brushes_used":0,"photos_added":0,"total_editor_actions":{},"tools_used":{},"is_sticker":false,"edited_since_last_sticker_save":false,"containsFTESticker":false}
“I Asked AI If Everton’s Controversial Penalty at Brighton Was Right – You Won’t Believe the Verdict on Joel Veltman and Referee Tim Robinson
AI’s Take on Yesterday’s Controversial Incident at the Amex Stadium
Brighton manager Fabian Hurzeler disagreed with Everton’s David Moyes, Joel Veltman was perplexed by referee Tim Robinson’s decision, and even the typically calm Gary Lineker expressed surprise at the call.
So, what exactly happened in yesterday’s controversial Premier League match where Everton triumphed 1-0 at the Amex Stadium?
Iliman Ndiaye took advantage of a handball decision on Brighton defender Joel Veltman, which was confirmed after VAR review.
Brighton argued that Veltman had been fouled when he brushed the ball with his right hand while going down under pressure from Everton’s substitute Beto.
Referee Robinson disagreed, and despite a strong second-half effort from the hosts, Brighton couldn’t recover.
The Premier League’s matchday centre clarified: “The VAR reviewed the potential handball by Veltman, judged it to be deliberate, and recommended an on-field review. The referee then awarded Everton a penalty.”
Veltman responded: “I was pushed from behind, which moved my hand forward, and the ball was there. It was more of a reaction than a deliberate handball. Without the push, I would have either headed it or cleared it with my feet.”
As expected, Hurzeler and Moyes had differing opinions, with Lineker, speaking on Match of the Day alongside pundits Alan Shearer and Danny Murphy, adding: “He was pushed by both players at full speed, and in slow motion, it looks a bit more like a penalty. But the fact we’re debating it raises the question: is it clear and obvious?”
VAR is only meant to intervene if the referee makes a “clear and obvious error.” Despite using advanced technology, a definitive conclusion remained elusive.
So, I turned to Grok AI—a generative AI designed to answer some of the toughest questions—to weigh in on the debate stemming from this East Sussex football match.
“The penalty awarded to Everton in their match against Brighton at the Amex Stadium sparked significant debate,” Grok began, before summarizing the situation and the reasoning behind the penalty.
It continued, “Brighton players, fans, and manager Fabian Hurzeler expressed frustration, with Hurzeler insisting it wasn’t a penalty, stressing that Veltman’s hand movement was a natural reaction to being pushed.”
Grok also noted, “On the other side, some Everton fans and commentators supported the decision, viewing Veltman’s hand movement as unnatural and intentional.”
It then elaborated on the evolving Premier League handball rules, which focus more on the arm’s natural position than intent, possibly explaining the VAR intervention.
In conclusion, Grok said, “The validity of the decision remains subjective, with opinions divided between the two fanbases. The crux of the debate centers on different interpretations of what constitutes a deliberate handball under current laws.”
Well, at least that clears things up!
